Stories
» Go to news mainAngiographic results of surgical or endovascular treatment of intracranial aneurysms: a systematic review and inter‑observer reliability study
Publication by Dr. David Volders.
Abstract
Purpose
Results of surgical or endovascular treatment of intracranial aneurysms are often assessed using angiography. A reliable method to report results irrespective of treatment modality is needed to enable comparisons. Our goals were to systematically review existing classification systems, and to propose a 3-point classification applicable to both treatments and assess its reliability.
Methods
We conducted two systematic reviews on classification systems of angiographic results after clipping or coiling to select a simple 3-category scale that could apply to both treatments. We then circulated an electronic portfolio of angiograms of clipped (n=30) or coiled (n=30) aneurysms, and asked raters to evaluate the degree of occlusion using this scale. Raters were also asked to choose an appropriate follow-up management for each patient based on the degree of occlusion. Agreement was assessed using Krippendorff’s α statistics (αK), and relationship between occlusion grade and clinical management was analyzed using Fisher’s exact and Cramer’s V tests.
Results
The systematic reviews found 70 different grading scales with heterogeneous reliability (kappa values from 0.12 to 1.00). The 60-patient portfolio was independently evaluated by 19 raters of diverse backgrounds (neurosurgery, radiology, and neurology) and experience. There was substantial agreement (αK=0.76, 95%CI, 0.67–0.83) between raters, regardless of background, experience, or treatment used. Intra-rater agreement ranged from moderate to almost perfect. A strong relationship was found between angiographic grades and management decisions (Cramer’s V: 0.80±0.12).
Conclusion
A simple 3-point scale demonstrated sufficient reliability to be used in reporting aneurysm treatments or in evaluating treatment results in comparative randomized trials.
Recent News
- Dr. Abraham receives CAIR Award
- Thank you to everyone who joined us for the 30th anniversary Radiology Research Day on May 8th!
- Nova Scotia’s Lung Screening Program expanding to Cape Breton, eastern mainland
- Donor‑supported nuclear medicine technology attracts top medical talent to the QEII
- Building Critical Skills at the Dalhousie Physician Leadership Workshop for Women in Radiology
- CAR/CSTR Practice Guideline on CT Screening for Lung Cancer
- CAR Practice Guideline on Bone Mineral Densitometry Reporting: 2024 Update
- CAR/CSACI Practice Guidance for Contrast Media Hypersensitivity